| Edgar "Howie" Borck '38 | One of Manhattan's most versatile track athletes. Competed in the 600 yards, 800 meters, and 1600 meter relays and was a champion in each. |
| James Houlihan '17 | Participated in both baseball and basketball. Was captain of both teams during his senior year. |
| Arthur Jocher '40 | Played football and earned All-Metropolitan, All-East, and All-American honors. Named NFL "Rookie of the Year" as a member of the Brooklyn Dodgers. |
| Larry Lembo '65 | Graduated as Manhattan's leading scorer with 1443 points and held that distinction for 13 years. Averaged 21.9 points per game for his career, still a Jasper record. |

