| P. Frasier Donlan '42 | Considered one of Manhattan's greatest football players. Known as the "iron man", Donlan was the Jaspers' starting tackle for 28 straight games. "Pat" was selected to the All-Met Team in 1942. Drafted by the football Brooklyn Dodgers following the '42 season. Former Pennsylvania State Senator. |
| Br. Gregory Hunt '50 | One of the College's most beloved figures. Served the College beginning in 1974 in the areas of Alumni Giving and Development. Long-time supporter of Jasper athletics. Started attending Manhattan's intercollegiate contests even before his association with the College began. |
| John O'Connell '53 | An outstanding sprinter, O'Connell was a member of Manhattan's 1952 sprint medley relay team that set a world record (1:52.7). Won the 1952 IC4A 60-yard dash in a record-tying 6.2 seconds. National AAU 60-yard champion in '52. Member of Manhattan's 440-yard and 880-yard relay record-setting teams. |
| Gerald Paulson '57 | Scored 1154 points during his Manhattan basketball career despite playing in a mere 69 games. Selected to play in the 1957 East-West College All-Star Game. Led team to post-season play in each of his three varsity seasons. Selected MVP of the ECAC Holiday Festival in '57. Played for the NBA's Cincinnati Royals during the 1957-58 season. |
| Robert "Red" Ronan '57 | Three-time selection to the Metropolitan Conference All-Star Team during his baseball career. Selected Second Team All-America as a first baseman. Member of 1957 Met Conference championship team. Two-year conference batting champion. Three-year leader in stolen bases and fielding pct. |
| Lisa Toscano '79 | One of Manhattan College's true pioneers of women's athletics. Four-year captain and co-founder of women's varsity basketball. Also helped establish the women's softball program. Also competed in volleyball and was one of the first female members of the crew team. Long-time trainer for Manhattan's men's and women's teams. |

